Axes are bookkeeping, not physics

  1. 01

    The tempting model

    Thinking a tilted coordinate system changes which forces are real.

  2. 02

    Why it feels right

    Once axes are drawn along a ramp, the component arrows can start to look like new forces.

  3. 03

    Where it breaks · how to catch it

    Your free-body diagram contains mg sin θ or mg cos θ as separate force arrows.

  4. 04

    The correct model

    Resolve vectors after listing real forces. Components are projections of one force into chosen axes; changing axes changes the algebra, not the interaction.

  5. 05

    Repair · see it, then test it

    worked example A block on an incline has gravity mg downward. How many gravity forces act?

    Tempting move

    Two: mg sin θ and mg cos θ.

    Correct move

    One force, mg downward. Its two components are bookkeeping along chosen axes.

    Test the repair NL-10 · transfer
    On an incline, a student draws mg downward plus mg sin θ down the ramp. What should change?

    Make a fresh prediction before referring to the worked example.