Energy conservation fails when external work is hidden
- 01
The tempting model
Applying KE + PE = const when friction, drag, or a motor is present.
- 02
Why it feels right
Total energy is conserved, but it is easy to mistake that statement for conservation of mechanical energy alone.
- 03
Where it breaks · how to catch it
You equated initial and final mechanical energy despite friction or an applied push.
- 04
The correct model
Mechanical energy is conserved only when non-conservative work is zero. Otherwise ΔKE + ΔPE = W_nonconservative (negative for friction).
- 05
Repair · see it, then test it
worked example A box slides down a rough ramp of height h. Is ½mv² = mgh?
Tempting move
Yes, energy is conserved.
Correct move
No — ½mv² = mgh − f·d; friction removes f·d as heat.
Test the repair EN-01 · transferMake a fresh prediction before referring to the worked example.
Then practise it on the ladder
R19Frictional loss over a pathadds: Friction work depends on path length.